(joint work with Katharina Paxman)

This chapter questions whether Hume thought that the minds of women were fundamentally different from those of men. We address this question with particular consideration of whether Hume’s account of women and gender roles is indicative of a gender essentialism or a gender constructivism.

We find that Hume’s account is mixed. While there are many examples in his writing of a sophisticated awareness of the ways in which ideas about gender are culturally constructed, he is also clearly committed to certain beliefs about fundamental, particularly physical, differences between men and women, and this results in a clear thread of gender essentialism. We argue that Hume’s gender essentialism can be usefully linked to his commitments to certain physiological theories of mind of his day, particularly those of sort espoused by Nicholas Malebranche.

You can download the full text of the paper here.

Recommended citation: Paxman, Katharina, and Kristen Blair. "Hume on the minds of women." In The Humean Mind, pp. 481-496. Routledge, 2018.